BMAD Profile Sync Report
This template records a manual reference review for the CLike-owned BMAD-aware methodology profile. It is not generated at runtime and it is not evidence of automatic upstream synchronization.
Reviewed BMAD Reference
- Reference name: BMAD Method
- Reference repository: https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD (MIT License)
- Reference documentation: https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD/tree/main/docs
- Reference version: v6.12.4 (
eecafe9d4bcad92166bee08623e0526009d862c4), checked 2026-11-15 - Reviewed version:
manual-review-pending - Reviewed commit:
manual-review-pending - Reviewed at:
manual-review-pending - Reviewed by:
manual-review-pending
Reviewed Materials
List the exact materials reviewed. Include release notes, repository paths, documentation pages, role definitions, workflow descriptions, checklist material, and any fixture workspace used for comparison.
manual-review-pending
Adopted Concepts
Record concepts adopted into the CLike-owned profile and explain where they appear in the manifest, agent profile, workflow profile, documentation, or tests.
- Agent responsibilities:
manual-review-pending - Workflow sequence:
manual-review-pending - Artifact expectations:
manual-review-pending - Handoff rules:
manual-review-pending - Checklist patterns:
manual-review-pending - Customization model:
manual-review-pending - Project-context model:
manual-review-pending
CLike Adaptation
Explain how each adopted concept was adapted to preserve Harper governance.
- CLike remains the governance runtime.
- Methodology is not executor.
- The orchestrator resolves
methodology_context. - Gateway is used only for cloud prompt composition.
local_agent_packageis the local-agent injection point.- EvalRunner remains authoritative.
- Gate remains CLike-owned.
- Candidate-first generation and write boundaries are preserved.
Excluded Concepts
Record concepts reviewed but intentionally excluded from the CLike profile.
- Runtime dependency: excluded.
- CLI execution: excluded.
- Uncontrolled writes: excluded.
- Gate authority: excluded.
- Copied official prompts: excluded.
- Latest auto-pulled in production: excluded.
Fixture Comparison Notes
Fixture workspace comparison is optional and manual only. If used, record the fixture location, scenario, generated artifacts, observations, and any CLike profile changes that resulted.
- Fixture workspace:
manual-review-pending - Scenario:
manual-review-pending - Observations:
manual-review-pending - Resulting CLike changes:
manual-review-pending
Scorecard And Verification Notes
Record whether deterministic scorecards were run and whether they were used only as review aids. Passing scorecard output does not prove live model quality.
- SPEC/PLAN/plan.json/lane-guide scorecard result:
manual-review-pending - IDEA native-vs-BMAD fixture scorecard result:
manual-review-pending - Gateway
prompt_debugreviewed:manual-review-pending - Local-agent
AGENT_EXECUTION_CONTEXT.jsonreviewed:manual-review-pending - Local-agent
AGENT_EVAL_CONTEXT.jsonreviewed:manual-review-pending - Companion artifact inventory reviewed:
manual-review-pending
Required Tests Before Merge
Run these before merging a profile sync:
python -m json.tool orchestrator/methodologies/bmad/manifest.json
python -m compileall orchestrator gateway
PYTHONPATH=orchestrator:. pytest -q orchestrator/tests/test_methodology_resolver.py orchestrator/tests/test_bmad_safety_boundaries.py orchestrator/tests/test_bmad_quality_contracts.py orchestrator/tests/test_bmad_quality_scorecard.py
Also run the implementation checklist safety grep for official BMAD package-runner and process-spawn patterns across orchestrator, gateway, extensions, docs, and README.md. It should produce no runtime invocation findings. If it returns documentation text, rewrite the documentation so it states the boundary without matching runtime-call patterns.
Current out-of-scope roadmap items include BMAD runtime execution, npx bmad-method runtime invocation, the BMAD importer, TEA, Party Mode, MCP write tools, multi-agent /spec --agents pm,ux, and automatic latest BMAD tracking at runtime. Do not mark any of these as reviewed current behavior unless the implementation actually exists.